I can’t go for ‘cry it out’ this time around
Monday
Sep 27, 2010
Lucy’s not sleeping well, and when Lucy’s not sleeping well, no one is.
I made the mistake of trying to solve this problem with a little help from some web forums when Abby was a baby, so I know enough to just commiserate and feel better at the end – avoid all the guilt. (If you ever want to feel like a horrible mother for suggesting your baby might be old enough to learn to calm herself down, search “cry it out” and read some of the crazy comments on the forums that pop up. Oooh, so not helpful.)
No, I’m fighting this battle alone (well, with Dave, whose ribs meet my elbow a few times a night: “Your turn.”) Lucy’ll wake three to five times a night, apparently because she – who can’t even coordinate bringing her hands to her mouth in a swift movement, has figured out that I exist and can be summoned with a cry. The little evil genius.
The Books That Know Everything But Don’t Tell You How to Actually DO These Things When It’s 3 in the Morning and You’re Exhausted suggest that I let her know I’m there for her – without going to her crib every time.
Oh, that’s helpful. I’ll send her an e-card. Maybe gift her a virtual pet on Facebook. You know, to let her know I’m thinking about her.
Rolling eyes here: No. Not helpful.
There’s wisdom less-tired people can grasp in that advice, but I am not less-tired people. I want to know how to tell a 4 ½ month old that I’m “there for her” when I really want to say “I’ll give you 20 bucks, kid, if you stay quiet ’til 6:30.”
See, there’s an older sibling involved. Abby wakes up for the slightest disturbance (and that unexpected fireworks show the other night at the college near our house did not qualify as a “slight” disturbance. Holy nightmare.) (Wow, that was a colorful vocab lesson at 10 o’clock at night.)
Anyhow, so I’m not about to let Lucy cry it out – not because I’m anti-CIO (as the moms are calling it these days, I hear) but because if I let Lucy cry it out, Abby’ll follow. Try explaining what 3 a.m. means to a toddler. Go ahead. Come on over and try it. See if YOU can talk her down from her demands: “I want UP, I want Froot Loops! I want’a wear pretty DRESS.” “It’s not time to wake up, lay down; we’ll get Froot Loops later.” “I WANT FROOT LOOPS.” “Shhh, it’s nighttime, it’s not breakfast –” “FROOT LOOOOOOPS!”
No, letting the baby cry it out isn’t on my game plan. But is waking up this often each night til she’s, what, 18 months old, part of my plan? Pffsh, no. I need another idea.

